Quality Ingredients

Our first priority is flavor, which means we use the highest quality ingredients available. Ethical, organic, humane, pastured, non GMO, and local are all ideal adjectives to describe our ingredients.  Sometimes local isn’t the most sustainable. Sometimes non-organic is better than organic if it has to be flown here. We get to know the farms and businesses from which we purchase so that we can make the most reasonable choices. You can rest assured that we are choosing ingredients based on what we would feed ourselves and our families.

Organic Grains

Our organic wheat flours come from Central Milling in Logan, Utah. It’s owned by the Giusto family who are renowned bakers, millers, and farmers. Their mill is powered from electricity generated by their own water turbine. Ben VanderWeele of VanderWeele Farms, in Palmer Alaska has been experimenting with growing wheat and it's going really well.  We all agree Ben’s Alaskan wheat (like everything grown in Alaska) is the best we’ve ever tasted. We mill it fresh, minutes before we hydrate it to lock in all of the nutrients before they are oxidized. We then ferment it for 18 hours to free up even more of the nutrition available from the grain. It makes for the sweetest whole grain bread we’ve ever had. It’ll definitely add a skip to your step. We also like to support farms that are preserving heritage grains. Brooke and Sam Lucy of Bluebird Grain Farms, in Winthrop Washington are doing just that. They grow heirloom grains like Emmer and Einkorn. These grasses are the strains found growing wild in the fertile crescent thousands of years ago. Anthropologists believe Emmer and Einka are among the primary factors that led hunter/gatherers to settle down and form communities. Besides the cultural impact, they taste amazing: full bodied with robust nutritional value. 

Organic Alaskan Produce and Meat

In Alaska, we enjoy some of the finest produce in the world. Sara and River Bean at Arctic Organics provide us with what we think is the best of the best. All summer they grow us fresh greens and herbs for our sandwiches and a variety of beautiful vegetables for our focaccias. The rest of the year they steadily supply us with their root vegetables: turnips, beets, carrots, potatoes, cabbage, and kohlrabi. The Beans are stewards of the land. During the long, dark winter months until the ground thaws and things begin to grow, we buy fresh greens and basil through Seeds of Change, here in Anchorage. They grow indoor hydroponics all year to keep our spirits up in January!  We have the greatest mushroom guy you could ask for.  Paul Benson at Cappricio Specialties brings us the most delicious fungus for our soups and focaccias. During Summer and Fall, he forages in his top secret spots nearby for wild mushrooms, fiddleheads, and devil’s club shoots. S.J. Klein at Alaska Sprouts makes incredibly fresh tofu for our tofu banh mi and deliciously fresh sprouts for our sandwiches year round.

Organic fair-trade coffee

Coffee is something that is near and dear to our hearts. We are bakers, however, so we don’t try and make espresso. We would never be satisfied and it would take our attention away from baked goods. Instead we make the best drip coffee we know. Michael McGuire at K Bay Caffe in Homer, Alaska is a nationally recognized roaster of organic, single origin, fair trade coffee. He is also a good person, purchasing his coffee from organic co-ops from around the world, and working hard on positive community growth in Homer.

Slow Traditional Methods

At Fire Island, finding the best ingredients is the first step. Then the real work begins. Every week we hand zest and juice cases of lemons, limes, and oranges. There is no substitute for fresh citrus. Plus the fresh-squeezed orange juice helps our bakers ward off colds. Every egg that comes through our doors is a whole, organic egg.  On a given day, over 400 eggs are separated into yolks and whites by hand. 

Alaska has a short growing season, so we must preserve the bounty in traditional ways in order to enjoy it year-round. We buy up all of the tomatoes that couldn’t quite ripen and pickled them for our pickled green tomato BLT. In our giant crock, we ferment hundreds of pounds of cabbage for our pastrami sandwich and hot peppers for our hot sauce that brightens up our breakfast sandwich. We brine whole brisket and cure whole pork bellies before smoking them in house for our pastrami and bacon.

ARTISAN BREAD

We mix, shape, proof, and bake our breads daily with the exception of two breads that improve with age. All breads contain some amount of starter (sourdough)  – be it a pre-ferment for the egg and dairy-rich breads such as the challah or onion poppy rolls, or a whole wheat, white, or rye levain (French for sourdough) for all the others. These starters give the breads a more complex and often tangy flavor. Our organic flour is from Central Milling in Utah – it is superb for artisan baking. They have their own bakery to test their flour daily for taste, color, and functionality. We like supporting a company that works directly with the farmers. Central Milling also generates their own electricity, powering their mill from a water turbine.

Caring for Your Bread: some steps to Ensure your bread stays fresh and delicious.  

Long Term Storage:  If you plan to eat your bread days down the road, the best thing is to freeze it.  Double bag your loaf and it can last up to 6 months in the freezer.  

Refreshing  bread:  Pre-heat your oven to 350F and bake 10 mins or until it smells like freshly baked bread.  If you have a loaf that has been sitting on your counter for a few days, spritz it with water before refreshing. This will help the crust crisp up again.

Slicing your bread:  To keep the your loaf as fresh as possible, we recommend you slice as needed.  The crust helps protect the soft crumb. Use a sharp, serrated knife using a long, light sawing motion. Let the knife do the work.

Short Term Storage:  The best place to store your loaf is in a paper bag or a bread box on the kitchen counter, cut side down.  Breathable paper allows the crust to stay crisp.  Refrigerators dehydrate the crumb and destroy the texture and flavor.

New York Times article "The Secret to Good Toast?  It's Your Freezer" by Emily Weinstein

DAILY BREADS

Onion Poppy Seed Rolls These rolls are flavored with poppy seeds and freshly diced yellow onions. They are light, soft, and sized for burgers and sandwiches (they’re more than just a dinner roll). This is an enriched dough made with milk and butter.

Pain Ordinaire Made from our wettest, longest fermented, old-world hand developed dough. This bread is made up of a blend of whole grain einka flour and high extraction wheat. Shaped into a 1 kilo miche.

Rustic Wheat Our signature bread! Simply high-extraction flour, whole wheat levain, salt, yeast, and water that is mixed, proofed, and baked to create a wholesomely tangy loaf.

Sliced Sandwich Bread Depending on the day, options include our Whole Wheat Pan, NY Rye, and our Prairie.

 

 

 

 

Baguette A traditional French baguette is the signature of a bakery. It took us a year and a half to develop a baguette that we were proud enough to sell at Fire Island. We bake a traditional and a seeded version throughout the day. An obvious favorite for our baguette-a-day customers.

Campagne Made with an aged levain to bring out the tangy, complex flavor, this bread contains organic white and wheat flour.

Ciabatta Our sandwich bread is available in large loaves and rolls. An elongated, flattish Italian bread good for almost any use. Chewy with big holes make it an excellent choice to dip in a great olive oil.

Emmer Einka Spelt A pan loaf containing emmer, einka, and spelt flours, emmer, einka and spelt berries, and sesame, flax, pumpkin, and sunflower seeds. This hearty loaf will be a welcomed addition to your backpack.

Focaccia An Italian flat bread untraditionally made with a type 85 flour that is lighter than 100% whole wheat but still very high in fiber. The focaccia is seasoned with extra virgin olive oil, salt, and various topping creations: sausage, cheddar, roasted potatoes, and egg; roasted vegetables and cheese; gorgonzola, walnuts, and green peas; roasted tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, and pesto; olives, feta, and roasted red peppers. 


SPECIALty BREADS This is a Selection of Breads we Make- See our menu for current details

Buckwheat Cinnamon Rolls Only buckwheat and whole wheat flours are used in our cinnamon rolls! Rich with sour cream, butter, and eggs, they are nut-free. Try them with or without maple cream cheese frosting. Baked on weekends only.

Caramelized Onion Thyme Richly caramelized onion and fresh thyme mixed into our campagne sourdough make for a perfect combination.

Challah A traditional braided bread rich with organic eggs, milk, and butter. Always sold on Friday, fresh for the Sabbath meals. Available plain or sprinkled with poppy or sesame seeds. Made in a crown with or without raisins for the holidays. 

Currant Pecan Our Rustic Wheat recipe full of roasted pecans and currants.

New York Rye A traditional NY-flavored rye made with onions and caraway seeds. A mixture of rye, whole wheat, and white flours.

Olive & Rosemary Our Alaska Sourdough loaf with Kalamata olives and roughly chopped fresh organic rosemary.  

Sliced Whole Wheat A light pan loaf made from 100% whole wheat flour. Perfect for sandwiches!

Vollkornbrot An old world wheat-free German rye bread that is dense, Pullman-shaped, and lasts for days. Ours is made from 100% pumpernickel flour and packed with flax seeds. Slice it thin and top with cream cheese and lox, or perhaps butter and apricot jam. European customers pair this with a strong cheese, tomato, and good stout. 

SCONES
How do we do it you may ask? Is it our small batches made quickly? The buckwheat flour? The tanginess of Nancy’s low fat yogurt? The hearth’s heat creating the near caramelization of the bottom of the scone? High-quality additions such as organic, unsulphured dried apricots or THE best dried cherries ever?

DAILY SCONES

Ham Cheddar Chive   A single muscle ham from Mat-Valley Meats paired with Dubliner cheddar and spicy green onion makes this the perfect savory treat.

Raspberry Lemon Zest   Our signature scone that’s been on the menu since day one – with lemon curd and raspberries.

Blackberry Rhubarb  Our sweet and satisfying scone dough sets the stage for an amazing combination of tart rhubarb and succulent blackberries.

MUFFINS


With the exception of the Beet Pecan Chevre, all our muffins are made with some percentage of whole-wheat or high-extraction flour (high-extraction flour lies somewhere between whole-wheat and white bread flour). All are hearty and not overly sweet.

DAILY MUFFINS

Über Blueberry  Lightly toasted wheat bran and plenty of blueberries easily make this muffin a breakfast favorite among many.

Lemon Poppy Seed The addition of extra virgin olive oil makes this a unique lemon poppy seed treat. This is a dairy-free, nut-free muffin.

Beet Chèvre This vibrantly colored muffin uses a puree of local organic beets, toasted pecans, and chèvre and is accented by a delicious orange streusel.

CAKES + CUPCAKES

To highlight the quality ingredients used in our cakes and butter creams we keep things simple. We believe in clean, bright flavors so we use the finest ingredients; dark cocoa, bourbon vanilla beans, toasted ground hazelnut. We let the ingredients speak for themselves and don't disguise them with excessive decorations or embellishments. Our cakes come in two sizes, a 4 inch small and a 6 inch large. Flavors change with the seasons, though we always have our chocolate cake available as it's become a local favorite.

For custom event and wedding cake inquiries please email us at: cakes.fireisland@gmail.com

Chocolate  Rich, bittersweet chocolate cake layered with buttery chocolate frosting.

Rosemary Orange This deliciously flavorful cake packs a punch with seasonal flavors and is topped with a vanilla glaze, sugared rosemary and candied orange peel. It doesn't get better than this gluten-free dessert!

Chocolate Cupcakes Chocolate cake topped with a dark chocolate frosting.

Counter Cake We sell these cakes by-the-slice or whole, if you feel like one slice won't be enough! Some of our favorite flavors include brown butter hazelnut, earl grey, and fresh fruit with whipped cream.

Baker's Choice Every month we feature a new cupcake flavor for our customers to enjoy. the flavors are largely seasonal and try to utilize as many local and in-season ingredients as possible. Past favorites include blueberry maple, strawberry shortcake, and a beet red velvet with a pistachio filling.

CROISSANT

Our world-class croissants are made with a combination of organic white and wheat flours giving them a distinctive nuttiness while retaining traditional flakiness and buttery goodness.

Traditional Croissant Our customers that travel the world tell us they no longer need to bring croissants home in their luggage.

Ham & Swiss A single muscle ham from Mat-Valley Meats is paired with Emmenthaler Swiss

Pain au Chocolat Our traditional croissant dough filled with European dark chocolate

 

 

DANISH + PASTRY

Danishes Fresh (and sometimes even local!) berries and vanilla bean pastry cream or frangipane, ensconced in our flaky croissant doug. 

Monkey Bread Our croissant dough rolled in cinnamon and brown sugar- come early; they sell out fast!

COOKIES

Our cookies are baked throughout the day because nothing beats a warm cookie.

Classic Chocolate Chip A classic, chewy chocolate chip cookie, totally loaded with bittersweet chocolate chips. The taste of the butter and chocolate can shine because we use less sugar.

Coconut Macaroon Simply shredded coconut, egg whites, and sugar cooked and baked to perfection. Also available dipped in chocolate.

Parisian Macaron A rarity in Alaska, these are light, chewy, almond meal and egg white-based sandwich cookies. Our macarons are lovely, subtle colors because Fire Island uses no chemical dyes in any of our baking. Our fillings are naturally flavored with lemon zest, berries, hazelnut, chocolate and other seasonal flavors. Pair with our unique wooden container to make a great gift.

Peanut Butter Crème Sweet, peanut butter ganache sandwiched between crisp peanut oatmeal cookies. This is the cookie that will get you to the top of Flat Top.

Stacked Shortbread Sold in stacks of 6 these melt-in-your-mouth cookies make the perfect treat to bring to a friend or on a picnic. We like to change it up so check in with us for our featured flavor! Some of our favorites include chocolate hazelnut, maple pecan, Earl Grey, and strawberry rosemary! Psst! They’re also vegan (but no one will believe you)!

Various Holiday Cookies Inquire on the holidays for individually-sold and decorated cookies, or special order a cookie platter for Hanuakkah or Christmas.  Trays vary from year to year but varieties include toffee, biscotti, fruit and oat bars, jam thumbprints, sesame wafers, Russian tea cakes, brownies, butter cookies, rugelach, macaroons, chocolate sandwich cookies, peeps, and more.

SANDWICHES: WE ARE CURRENTLY UPDATING OUR SANDWICH MENU. PLEASE GIVE OUR SHOPS A CALL TO FIND OUT WHAT WE’RE MAKING TODAY!

Our sandwiches throughout the year and are made fresh using our very own freshly-baked breads. We draw upon the best quality ingredients we can lay our hands on – from artisanal, cured meats to local, seasonal vegetables and herbs. Our spreads, slaws and condiments are all made in-house.

SOUP

Our soups rotate based on season, produce availability, and our Chef's inspiration but some of our favorites include matzoh ball, creamy tomato, carrot almond with browned butter, and salmon chowder.

THIS + THAT

Ethiopia Yiragacheffe’ Coffee Organic, fairly traded coffee beans supplied from K Bay Coffee, an artisan roaster in Homer. We brew our coffee in small batches,  so we are sure to have fresh coffee throughout the day. We pay attention to drip coffee in ways that places that serve espresso don’t.

Birdseed Bar Made from sesame seeds, pumpkin seeds, sunflower seeds, dried cherries, and coconut. Delicious and vegan, gluten-free and nut-free.

Bourbon Bread Pudding A clear customer (and staff) favorite! This incredible treat comes in a personal size or big enough to share and is loaded with chewy chunks of our sourdough bread, golden raisins and toasted pecans. We top it off with a bourbon glaze and a dusting of sucre neige.

Granola An all organic mixture of rolled oats, kamut, spelt, barley, wheat bran, and toasted almonds, lightly sweetened with honey.

Dietary Resctrictions

At Fire Island, our first priority is always flavor. We use only the finest ingredients, and do not make substitutions. This means all of our products taste wonderful. Our vegan, dairy-free and gluten-free products are intended for everyone to enjoy – not just those with dietary restrictions.

Please note that although Fire Island makes every effort to prevent cross-contamination, we are a small shop and cannot entirely prevent it. Therefore, if you have a serious allergy that may require medical intervention, we implore you to shop elsewhere.

With the exception of certain focaccia, scones, croissants and sandwiches, all of our breads and baked goods are vegetarian, and many are vegan. We have a complete ingredient list for every item that we make, so please do not hesitate to ask at the counter.   Also ask about our daily soup, we may just have the perfect option for you.

DAIRY-FREE

Almond Granola
Birdseed Bars
Baguettes
Ciabatta
Coconut Macaroon
Emmer Einka Spelt
Campagne (Sesame, Olive Rosemary, Walnut Sage, Herbes de Provence)
Lemon Poppy Seed Muffins
Rustic Wheat (Currant Pecan)
Pain Ordinaire
Sliced Prairie
Vollkornbrot
Shortbread Cookie Stack

 

GLUTEN-FREE

Raspberry Almond Cake
Birdseed Bars
Chocolate Macaroons
Coconut Macaroons
Parisian Macaron
Salted Caramel Tart
 

VEGAN

Almond Granola (contains honey)
Birdseed Bars
Baguettes
Ciabatta
Emmer Einka Spelt
Campagne (Sesame, Olive Rosemary, Walnut Sage, Herbes de Provence)
Rustic Wheat (Currant Pecan)
Pain Ordinaire
Sliced Prairie
Vollkornbrot
Shortbread Cookie Stack

CONTAINS NUTS

Almond Rosemary Polenta Cake
Almond Granola
Apple Bourbon Pecan Scone
Bourbon Bread Pudding
Carrot Cake
Currant Pecan Rustic Wheat
Focaccia (sometimes)
Frangipane Danish
Monthly Cupcake (sometimes)
Parisian Macarons
Peanut Butter Créme Cookie
Pecan Tart
Rugelach
Salted Caramel Tart
Vegan Shortbread Cookies (sometimes)